Thanks to Linh for cajoling me into reading/watching this series. I've always been the late bird, what with joining friendster and facebook and watching madagascar and a billion zillion other things. Same went for this.
I think I should have watched the movie first, then read the series. Same as what I did for Memoirs of a geisha, because novel-based movies are almost always inferior to the original, which should be the general view of half of Twilight fans out there, but I'm giving both the movie and the books a try. With very forgiving eyes.
That said, I'm sitting on the fence for this one.
Movie first.
It was average, and mildly enjoyable. The whole point was to ogle at Robert Pattison, matching him against my expectations for Edward Cullen. He passed, partially because I recently had an obsession with any English actors, of which Ed Westwick (Chuck Bass - Gossip girl) is one.
And then I found myself paying very close attention to Kristen Stewart's facial features as well (no I'm not a lesbian thank you very much). The girl bears a resemblance to Emma Watson (Hermione - Harry Potter), in this movie at least. People were disappointed with Kristen as Bella (which they also did for Robert Pattison - "the Rob effect", as dubbed by Meyer herself). Not beautiful enough, you say? Sometimes you've got to accept that real people, albeit with make-up, can hardly fare against otherworldly beauties stemming from imagination running wild. IMO she was appropriate enough; it fits with the image of a girl deemed "plain" by fellow females, but had half (was it?) of the male population swooning (not that I would know what guys - real ones - would think).
I guess I'm now set on black-eyed black-haired English guys, and brown-eyed brown-haired for girls.
Linh said she didn't like Kristen Stewart's acting - it wasn't intense enough to express Bella's burning love for Edward. But hmm, I like. The shy and easily startled girl with very nice brown eyes isn't easy to miss. So is the slight awkwardness between their conversations, which makes it easier for most to relate ourselves (ah well, at least count me in!). You don't expect smoothly over-flowing words between the two, do you?
For the sake of preventing myself from being labelled as a lesbian, I shall input some thoughts for Robert Pattison. Which has me realise I've got nothing to say about him. Was it because his acting was just bland, or did I waste my time studying their physical appearance and forgetting everything else?
On an unrelated note, I went for the movie alone under circumstances explained in previous post. The woman at the counter was giving me this very weird look when I said "ticket for one". And surrounded me in the cinema were couples, couples, more couples, and friends going in groups and groups. Now that woman must've thought I'm either a voluntary movie critic, or a heart-broken teenage girl; she seemed to have decided on the latter. Man, must I've looked terrible!
Now is the novel.
Honestly, it felt like reading a fan-fiction - the writing with crammed adverbs and adjectives is much too familiar. And the plot. Holy cow, another damsel in distress (which Bella herself admitted)! Harp all you want; I bet 70% of the fanbase is teenage girls (no offense to male fans, although I'd like not my future boyfriend to be enjoying this). It makes (some of) us feel like Bella is all over Edward because of his looks, and maybe his vampiric abilities alone. In one word: flat, which is also the case for Edward. I wondered where is their love based on if not all these purely physical attributes. You may argue that Edward's unceasing devotion and passion for Bella is not to be ignored, but it wasn't made clear in the novel where this all is coming from either, except that he found it hard to detach himself from her for if he did she would be severely harmed - "a magnet for troubles" to quote Edward - which brings me back to "damsel in distress" point.
And so is the whole "imprinting" thing. Love is a give-and-take process. If it's already rendered involuntary and unexplained in one way, what is there left to offer for the other? It leaves no place for personality, because to quote Jacob (I think), "it's hard to resist such a degree of devotion". The concept of "destined lovers" is hardly my cup of tea.
Meyer claimed her success despite - or should I say, thanks to - all this elements, which should - and have - hit very hard into the mind of romance-yearning teenage girls. I won't deny that I'm one, in case you all want to burn me on the stake for saying all this.
On 2nd note, I took FB quizzes revolving around "who's your best twilight guy", and the result has been much to my pleasure:
- Edward
- Jasper
- Edward
- Jasper
- Carlisle (okay that was unexpected, but bearable)
- Edward
- Edward
- Edward
- Emmett (Ew. EW.)
- Jasper
Personally, throughout the movie and books, my favourite character would be Jasper.
JASPER FTW :D :D :D